LEPSUSYWG/02-09.2

LEP2 SUSY Working Group

Combined LEP GMSB Stau/Smuon/Selectron Results, 189-208 GeV

ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL Experiments


R.Alemany, C.Booth, F.Cerutti, B.Clerbaux, A.Garcia-Bellido, P.Giacomelli, N.Kanaya, K.Klein, T.Marchant,  R.McPherson, C.Rembser, S.Rosier, U.Schwickerath, L.Xia


Introduction :

The LEP experiments have searched for staus/smuons/selectrons in the data taken during year 2000 at centre-of-mass energies ranging from 204 GeV to 209 GeV. In the GMSB model, the gravitino is the LSP and the sleptons can be the NLSP. Their decay length is arbitrary and depends on the gravitino mass (proportional to the SUSY breaking scale). Hence the LEP experiments used various analyses to be sensitive to all ranges of slepton lifetime:

No signal has been found. Constraints have been derived in the context of GMSB, combining the data set from the year 2000 with those taken at lower energies during the years 1999 and 1998.

References to individual experiments:

The theoretical framework is described e.g.:

Analysis:

Cross sections and branching ratios have been calculated in the framework of the GMSB model (S.Dimopoulos, S.Thomas, J.D.Wells), performing a scan over the parameters

searching for a minimum cross sections and branching ratio at each slepton mass. Efficiencies, backgrounds, and candidates have been reported by the groups in a grid of slepton mass and slepton lifetime (45 GeV< m < 103 GeV in steps of 1 GeV and -12 < log(tau) < -6 in steps of delta(log(tau))=0.2). The LEP collaborations -ADLO- provided this information for staus and ADO for selectrons/smuons. The confidence level is computed using the multichannel likelihood ratio method developped by T.Junk (Confidence level computation for combining searches with small statistics, T.Junk CARLETON-OPAL-PHYS-99-01, CERN-EP-99-041, Feb 1999. 17pp., Nucl.Instrum.Meth.A434:435-443,1999, e-Print Archive: hep-ex/9902006.) 

(You can click on the image to get the postscript file.)

Preliminary results:
stau1 (stau NLSP) ADLO, 189-209 GeV
smuonR (slepton NSLP) ADO, 189-209 GeV
selectronR (slepton NLSP) ADO, 189-209 GeV

number of obs./exp./signal events, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


(1.-CLB), sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV (on logarithmic scale)


excluded cross section times branching ratio squared, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


excluded mass as a function of stau lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV, expected limit and 1,2-sigma bands are shown


excluded mass as a function of stau lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV, expected limit and lines of equal beta*gamma*c*tau at sqrt(s)=208 GeV are shown to indicate the different lifetime regimes


maximum excluded cross section x B.R.^2 + mass limit for all lifetimes, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


number of obs./exp./signal events, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


(1.-CLB), sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV (on logarithmic scale)


excluded cross section times branching ratio squared, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


excluded mass as a function of smuon lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV, expected limit and 1,2-sigma bands are shown


excluded mass as a function of smuon lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV, expected limit and lines of equal beta*gamma*c*tau at sqrt(s)=208 GeV are shown to indicate the different lifetime regimes


maximum excluded cross section x B.R.^2 + mass limit for all lifetimes, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


number of obs./exp./signal events, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


(1.-CLB), sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV (on logarithmic scale)


excluded cross section times branching ratio squared, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV


excluded mass as a function of selectron lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV (N=1,2,3,4,5), expected limit and 1,2-sigma bands are shown


excluded mass as a function of selectron lifetime, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV (N=1,2,3,4,5), expected limit and lines of equal beta*gamma*c*tau at sqrt(s)=208 GeV are shown to indicate the different lifetime regimes


maximum excluded cross section x B.R.^2 + mass limit for all lifetimes (N=1,2,3,4,5), sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV

limit staus (all lifetimes) for all N
m(stau) > 86.9 GeV at 95%C.L.
limit smuons (all lifetimes) for all N
m(smu) > 96.3 GeV at 95%C.L.
limit selectrons (all lifetimes) (N=1,2,3,4,5),
m(sel) > 65.8 GeV at 95%C.L.

 
The left plot shows an example of the excluded /\-tan(beta) region for a fixed set of parameters (N=2, M=250TeV and mu>0) combining the slepton results (yellow) with the results of the LEP acoplanar photon search (blue). For this particular scenario, assuming a short lifetime of the NLSP, values of /\ less than 35.5 TeV can be excluded for tan(beta) = 15. On the plot, the black region indicates the LEP1 search region, grey regions are not excluded (here the light grey indicates the region which can not be reached with LEP2 energies).
The parameters were chosen to compare the LEP results to prospects of the TEVATRON run 2 (right plot).


(You can click on the image to get the postscript file.)

Search for long lived / stable charged particles:

In case for the search for long lived particles with a lifetime greater/equal 10E-6 s, slepton masses less than 97.5 GeV can be excluded at 95% C.L.. This limit corresponds to the long lifetime results of the stau and smuon GMSB searches, see above.
If the slepton is stable, then the large impact parameter and kinked track search do not contribute to the analysis. Results of the search for stabkle particles are given on a separate page.
 
Search for long lived charged particles,
tau greater/equal 10E-6 s
ADLO, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV
Search for STABLE heavy charged particles
ADLO, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV

excluded cross section and mass for a slepton, lifetime > 10E-6s, sqrt(s)=189-209 GeV
results of the search for STABLE heavy charged particles are given on a seperate page.
M > 97.5 GeV at 95% C.L.
The histogram which gives the excluded cross section for long lived sleptons has a dip in the exclusion around the mass of 60 GeV.
Reason for this dip is a reduced efficiency of the experiments which use as their main search tool an analysis of the specific ionisation energy loss in the tracking chambers to separate heavy charged particles from Standard Model (SM) particles.
Possible candidates would appear in the region indicated by the green boxes on the left plot, the example of a particle with a mass of 45 GeV is given by the dark green line. In the region in between the boxes, new heavy particles can not be separated from SM particles. Examples of SM particles are given by the blue lines. But as LEP2 was running at various beam energies (which means that the momentum of a pair produced new particle with a certain mass varied, too), new heavy charged particles at all masses at least once should appear in the "separation regions".

The two additional dips in the excluded cross section for particles with a lifetime of tau=10E-6s are caused by two ALEPH candidates in the large impact parameter search at 189 GeV and 198 GeV. These candidates contribute to the long lifetime region as for particles with a mass close to the beam energy, their beta*gamma (=p/e * e/m = p/m = sqrt(E**2 - m**2)/m, with E = half of the beam energy) gets very small, hence the decay can still occure inside the detector.


Christoph Rembser, September 2002